Fall is more than just Pumpkin Spice Latte season—it’s a time for cozy flavors, seasonal spices, and the comfort of a warm cup in your hands. But for seasoned Starbucks fans, there’s a whole world beyond the official fall menu. The Starbucks secret menu drinks are unofficial creations—clever combinations shared by baristas and customers—that bring a whole new level of flavor to your coffee experience.
Whether you’re looking for something sweet and indulgent or bold and spiced, this list of the 10 best secret drinks to try this fall 2025 offers the perfect excuse to change up your coffee routine. Just remember: secret menu drinks aren’t pre-listed, so you’ll need to know the customizations. Don’t worry—we’ve got you covered!
1. Pumpkin Pie Frappuccino
This creamy, dessert-like treat is the ultimate fall indulgence. It tastes exactly like a slice of pumpkin pie blended with ice, milk, and whipped topping.
How to Order:
-
Start with a Pumpkin Spice Crème Frappuccino as your base (no coffee)
-
Ask for 1–2 pumps of cinnamon dolce syrup
-
Request extra whipped cream to be blended in, not just on top
-
Finish with cinnamon powder or nutmeg sprinkles for that pie-like finish
Why It’s a Must-Try:
The texture is rich and velvety, and the cinnamon kick enhances the earthy pumpkin notes. It’s a nostalgic sip that evokes cozy family gatherings and Thanksgiving vibes.
2. Caramel Apple Spice Float
Think of your favorite hot apple cider—but with a sweet, creamy twist that makes it feel like a float.
How to Order:
-
Order a standard Caramel Apple Spice (steamed apple juice, cinnamon syrup, whipped cream, and caramel drizzle)
-
Ask to top it with vanilla sweet cream cold foam instead of whipped cream
-
For a frothier experience, request a splash of apple juice blended into the foam
What Makes It Special:
The contrast between the warm cider base and chilled foam is refreshing yet comforting. The vanilla notes bring a mellow sweetness that tastes like apple pie à la mode.
3. Snickerdoodle Cold Brew
A treat for cookie lovers, this iced coffee creation mimics the flavor of snickerdoodle cookies—sweet, buttery, and with a strong cinnamon presence.
How to Order:
-
Ask for a Vanilla Sweet Cream Cold Brew
-
Add 1 pump of cinnamon dolce syrup (2 for larger sizes)
-
Request a sprinkle of cinnamon powder on top
Flavor Profile:
Bold cold brew provides the energy kick, while the cinnamon-vanilla combo gives it that sugary, baked-goods warmth. It’s a fantastic pick-me-up during the midday slump.
4. S’mores Hot Chocolate
A comforting nod to fireside treats, this rich hot chocolate feels like a warm hug on a crisp evening.
How to Order:
-
Begin with a regular hot chocolate
-
Add 1 pump each of mocha syrup and toffee nut syrup
-
Request whipped cream and graham cracker topping (or cinnamon dolce topping if graham isn’t available)
Why You’ll Crave It:
The toasted marshmallow flavor, gooey chocolate, and buttery graham hints recreate the iconic campfire dessert in beverage form. Great for both kids and adults.
5. Cinderella Latte
A fan-created favorite that blends pumpkin and white chocolate into a fairy tale of flavor.
How to Order:
-
Ask for a Pumpkin Spice Latte
-
Request half the usual pumpkin spice syrup be replaced with white mocha syrup
Taste Experience:
The white mocha softens the spice of the pumpkin, creating a perfectly balanced and slightly sweeter version of the classic PSL. Ideal for those who want to embrace fall without too much heat from spices.
6. Apple Crisp Oatmilk Macchiato with Caramel Swirl
This elevated twist on a seasonal favorite adds richness and layered sweetness.
How to Order:
-
Start with the Apple Crisp Oatmilk Macchiato
-
Add extra caramel drizzle on the cup walls and the top foam
-
Ask for a splash of brown sugar syrup if available
What It Tastes Like:
The result is a beautifully layered drink with roasted apple flavor, creamy oat milk texture, and buttery caramel undertones—like sipping on a warm apple cobbler.
7. Dirty Chai Pumpkin Latte
Two iconic fall beverages—chai and pumpkin spice—join forces in this bold and aromatic drink.
How to Order:
-
Order a chai tea latte
-
Add one shot of espresso (two if you need an extra boost)
-
Request 1–2 pumps of pumpkin spice syrup
Flavor Breakdown:
You get the spicy complexity of chai, the deep roast of espresso, and the sweet warmth of pumpkin all in one. It’s ideal for those who want both energy and flavor sophistication.
8. Sweet Potato Pie Latte
A hidden gem of the secret menu, this drink offers an earthy, sweet flavor similar to a baked sweet potato dessert.
How to Order:
-
Start with a Pumpkin Spice Latte
-
Add 1–2 pumps of brown sugar syrup (or toffee nut if unavailable)
-
Top with whipped cream and a sprinkle of cinnamon dolce topping
Why It Stands Out:
Unlike the traditional PSL, this version is less spicy and more mellow, offering a nutty sweetness that feels both comforting and unique.
9. Mocha Nutcracker
This bold and festive blend is inspired by holiday flavors but works wonderfully for early fall cravings too.
How to Order:
-
Order a Mocha Latte
-
Add 1 pump of hazelnut syrup
-
Top with cinnamon powder and optional chocolate curls (if available)
How It Tastes:
Rich mocha blends with nutty hazelnut and a subtle spice from the cinnamon to create a decadent drink reminiscent of Ferrero Rocher chocolates.
10. Toasted Chestnut Praline Latte
Warm, roasted, and just a bit fancy, this drink is fall luxury in a cup.
How to Order:
-
Begin with a Chestnut Praline Latte
-
Swap the standard milk for steamed milk.
-
Add a pump of toasted vanilla syrup for depth (if available)
-
Finish with the standard praline topping
Sip Experience:
Each sip is nutty and buttery with a smooth toasted undertone. It’s sophisticated, cozy, and perfect for sipping slowly on a chilly day.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. Can I order Starbucks secret menu drinks through the mobile app?
Some drinks can be customized via the Starbucks app if you know the ingredients. However, certain modifications or toppings might require in-person ordering, so it’s best to visit your local store for more complex creations.
2. Are secret menu drinks only available at certain locations?
Generally, all Starbucks locations can make these drinks as long as they have the ingredients. Limited-time syrups (like pumpkin spice or apple crisp) may vary by region and availability.
3. How should I order a secret menu drink if the barista doesn’t recognize it?
Always order by specifying the base drink and modifications rather than the drink’s nickname. Baristas don’t have an official “secret menu,” so giving clear instructions ensures you get what you want.
4. Do these drinks contain caffeine?
Most do, especially if they include espresso, cold brew, or chai. However, options like the Pumpkin Pie Frappuccino or S’mores Hot Chocolate can be made caffeine-free if you ask for a crème base or hot chocolate without coffee.
5. Can I adjust the sweetness of these drinks?
Yes! You can request fewer syrup pumps, sugar-free alternatives, or milk options to reduce sugar and calories. Baristas are typically happy to accommodate.
Conclusion: Turn Your Fall Coffee Runs Into Flavor Adventures
With so many cozy, creative choices on the Starbucks secret menu drinks list, fall 2025 is the perfect season to try something new. Whether you’re craving the nostalgia of pumpkin pie, the comfort of apple spice, or a bold espresso twist, there’s a secret drink that will hit the spot.
So next time you’re in line, surprise your taste buds and treat yourself to one of these hidden treasures. Don’t forget to share your favorites on social and tag your friends—you might just inspire someone else’s new go-to order.
